Tag Archives: republicanism

Fṛm Đ Gardịn: I have never felt more lonely in my republicanism, or more wedded to it

‘While the Queen’s death has entrenched my republicanism, it seems to have done the opposite to much of the country.’ Photograph: Reuters
‘Ẃl ɖ Qīn’z deʈ hz intrenćt mî rpublic̣nizm, it sīmz t hv dn ɖ oṗzit t mć v ɖ cuntri.’ Foṭgraf: Rôtrz

I hv nvr flt mor lonli in mî rpublic̣nizm, or mor wedd t it

(Transcription of an article published in the Guardian on 20 September 2022)

F y apruv v ɖ cuṛnt sistm, y’r cmitd t prizrvñ iniqoḷti, ẃɖr yr roylizm z ‘soft’ or nt

Moya Lothian-McLean

Moia Loɖịn-McLīn, Tyzde 20 Sptmbr 2022

I  hv olwz harbrd a sīcrit fir ɖt I cd b a “soft roylist”. Ɖ ingrīdịnts wr ol ɖr: I’m a hisṭribuf hu z faṣnetd bî ɖ maṣ́neśnz – n sordid gosip – srǎndñ Britn’z monarcs v yor; I hv a wìcnis fr nstalja; I ǒn ɖ updetd vrśn v Tīna Brǎn’z 2007 bạgraficl oṗs v Dîana, Prinsis v Wêlz. I hv no ptiklr prsnl dslîc v ɖ roylz az indivijlz n I hv faund mslf fīlñ trūli simṗʈetic, sć az ẃn Qīn Iliẓbʈ II lost hr huzbnd v 73 yirz jrñ locdǎn.

Bt ɖ past 12 dez hv rvild jst hǎ stōnć mî rpublicn prínsiplz riyli r; ɖe forṭfaid ɖm, in fact. It sīmz obvịs: rɖr ɖn pasñ ɖ septr, w śd b tecñ ɖs oṗtyṇti t ʈro it on t ɖ scraphīp v hisṭri. Nvr hz ɖ fix́n v a dvîn rît t rūl sīmd so ʈredbér.

Sanwijd btwn wōl-t-wōl cuṿrij peyñ tribyt t ɖ dsist moṇc, or ɖ lîv blogz dsctñ ɖ mīnñ v ɖ prl ćocr sportd bî ɖ Prinsis v Wêlz in Wsminstr Abi, multipl storiz tsṭfî t ɖ sspnśn v comn-sns rqîrd t mnten ɖ xistns v ɖ roylz, jusṭfayñ canṣlñ medicl apôntmnts in ɖ midl v a dedli NHS baclog, or argywñ fr ɖ rît v ɖ ny cñ nt t pe inheritnstax on ɖ hundṛdz v miłnz h hz inheṛtd fṛm hiz muɖr.

Yt ẃl riax́n t ɖ Qīn’z deʈ hz intrenćt mî rpublic̣nizm, it sīmz t hv dn ɖ oṗzit t mć v ɖ cuntri. Ɖ oṿẃlmñ mît v tṛdiśn hz wrct its heɉmonic majic n ralid s’port fr ɖ roylz, īvn amñ mî pirz, ɖ mć tǎtd “yuñ Brits” hu hd s’pozidli “trnd ɖer bacs on ɖ moṇci”.

YGuv poulñ fṛm 11 Sptmbr faund ɖt ẃl 18- t 25-yir-olds wr mor unśur abt ɖ moṇci ɖn oldr cohorts, 40% stl s’portd its xistns; ɖs figr hits 53% amñ 25- t 49-yir-olds. Cñ Ćarlz hz injoid a sgnificnt būst in popylaṛti sins sufixñ hiz nem wɖ III – ɖ sem srve faund ɖ psntij v ppl wilñ t agri wɖ ɖ stetmnt ɖt h wd “mc a gd cñ” hd incrist fṛm 32% in Me t 63% last wīc. Yungr rspondnts r les ifysiv in ɖer s’port fr him, bt it z stl ɖr.

Deta olso sjsts ɖt rpublicn sntimnts hld ẃl yungr r lîcli t b irodd bî ej. Onli 14% v undr-35z wr wilñ t se ɖ moṇci wz “vri importnt” t Britn in 2021, in contrast wɖ 44% v ɖoz ejd 55 n ovr. Acordñ t ɖ poulmevn Jon Crtis, ɖs z a historicl patn – ɖt gap z mć ɖ sem az it wz in 1994. Ɖoz hu hv cōśnd rpublicnz isnṣ́li t wêt ǎt a śort-trm būst v s’port fr ɖ roylz aftr ɖ Qīn’z deʈ me fînd ɖmslvz dis’pôntd.

Īvn armd wɖ ɖt riylizm, it z stl jarñ t woć so mni fōl intu lîn, on cy. Ɖr r difṛnt subsx́nz, v cors: fṛm ɖ dîhard, cmitd Roylists-wɖ-a-capitl-R, t ɖoz hu clem rpublicn tndnsiz bt hv faund ɖmslvz cpić̣letñ in ɖ fes v ɖ stet mśīn, siyñ it az a marc v “rspct” t Iliẓbʈ nt t activli opoz ɖ cntinyeśn v ɖ moṇci via hr sun.

Mini culćrworz r pleyñ ǎt via public mōrnñ. Az a frend ʈiyrîzd rlịr ɖs wīc, fr sm (mostli sntrist n rîtwñ mīdịpundits, it hz t b sd) moṇcizm hz bcm a mīnz v “leftbaśñ” – si ɖ lîcs v Dan Wŭtn v GB Nyz, hu hz loñ perd hiz tîrsm “wor on wouc” wɖ royl cuṿrij so sic̣fantic y sspct īvn ɖ Winzrz me fînd it dstestfl. Wn inṭrestñ x’sîz in tracñ p’liticl fragmnteśn z lcñ at ɖ s’portrz v ɖ preśrgrūp Rpublic fṛm 2012 – it’s hard t imajin ɖoz nemz ynîtñ fr eni comn cōz tde.

Ɖen ɖr’z ɖ “roylist or nt, it’s hard nt t b muvd bî ɖs seḷbreśn v ɖ Qīn” aproć, ẃć sīmz t includ yungr ppl wontñ t ptec v sm – partli mańfacćrd – c’lectiv fīlñ. It’s a sriyl fīlñ t b sudnli so ǎt on a lim fr ʈncñ: “Wel, acć̣li, it’s vri īzi nt t b muvd.” F I’m muvd t eni ptiklr imośn, it z angr ɖt inforst mōrnñ wl brñ frɖr suḟrñ t ɖ olrdi struġlñ, ɖt dsntñ vôsz r biyñ rprest, ɖt ɖ consept v “rspct” z biyñ invoct bî so mni n yt afordd t so fy.

On Saṭde, I pśt mî we ʈru ʈroñz v royl mōrnrz in sntṛl Lundn on mî we t a smōlr gaɖ̇rñ, jst yardz awe, ǎtsd Ny Scotḷnd Yard. Ɖ demo wz t protest at ɖ p’līs śūtñ v an unarmd 24-yir-old Blac man, Cris Kaba. Az w std ɖr, liṣnñ t ɖ hart-ec v Kaba’z b’rivd faṃli n frendz, alñ wɖ reḷtivz v sm v ɖ 1,833 ppl hu hv daid aftr contact wɖ ɖ p’līs in Ñgḷnd n Wêlz in ɖ past 32 yirz, a wmn stōct past n śǎtd, “Smwn’z muɖr hz daid.”

It wz a momnt so sriyl, ɖ vayḷns – n I d’nt yz ɖt wrd lîtli – v it so śocñ, it wz hard t fŭli comprihnd. Ɖ sntimnt, so ofn sîḷnt hd bn utrd, lǎd n clir. Wn lîf z nt īql t anɖr. T liv in a cuntri guvnd bî roylti mīnz fiylti nt jst in dīd bt in ʈōt. It mīnz a cmitmnt – ofn unconśs – t prizrvñ ineqti, ẃɖr ɖ roylizm z “soft” or nt. Phps sm de sn, rpublic̣nizm wl rgen its nonparṭzan ftñ. Bt untl ɖen, I nǒ ẃr I stand, n I hv nvr bn mor śr v biyñ wedd t sć an unpopylr b’lif.

• • •

Moia Loɖịn-McLīn z a cntribytñ editr at Novara Mīdia

Instroduction to Ñspel

Fṛm Đ Gardịn: Amid the mourning, we republicans should look and learn – but we must not be silenced

‘Discussion of the monarchy, our politics, our constitution, is something to be vigorously aired.’ Photograph: Adam Vaughan/EPA
‘Dscuśn v ɖ moṇci, ǎr poḷtics, ǎr consttyśn, z smʈñ t b vigṛsli erd.’ Foṭgraf: Adm Vōn/YPA

Amd ɖ mōrnñ, w rpublicnz śd lc n lrn – bt w mst nt b sîḷnst

(Transcription of an article published in the Guardian on 16 September 2022)

Olɖo ɖ arğmnts agnst ɖs sistm v priṿlij r stroñ, it z importnt t unḍstand ẃ it indyrz

Clive Lewis

Clîv Luis, Frîde 16 Sptmbr 2022

Ɖs wīc hz bn dificlt fr ɖoz v s hu wont t si a fŭli dmocṛtîzd, 21st-snć̣ri poḷti ɖt dz’nt hv a hreditri biłner az its hed v stet. Evrʈñ fṛm ɖ gṛćuiṭs wōl-t-wōl mīdịcuṿrij t ɖ arest v anti-moṇci pṛtstrz n ɖ stet-sañśnd canslculćr v ɖoz hu dsnt hz leid bér ɖ fact ɖt ɖs trnziśn z az mć abt coŕśn az cnsnt.

Bt, strenjli, ɖz acts hv nt bn ɖ most dificlt ʈñ t recnsîl in ɖs tymultẏs wīc. Instd, it hz bn woćñ ɖ lîvstrīm v tnz v ʈǎzndz v felositiznz fṛm ol wōcs v lîf, qaytli kwñ fr p t nîn aurz t fîl past a cofin ẃl bawñ n crtsiyñ. Mî iniśl rspons wz wn v b’ḿzmnt foloud bî a tuć v dsper. Ẃ, I asct, wd so mni ppl, ofn wɖ so litl, śo sć defṛns t an insttyśn ɖt z ɖ vri imbodimnt v ɖ iniqoḷtiz v wlʈ n pǎr ɖt prmiet ǎr cuntri? Bcz untl rpublicnz cn fŭli unḍstand ɖs sntimnt, w wl strugl t win ɖ arğmnt fr trnziśn fṛm consttyśnl moṇci t consttyśnl dmocṛsi.

T gen ɖt insît y nīd onli lisn t ɖ sem ppl inṭvyd, olmst cntinẏsli, on teḷviźn n ɖ redio abt ẃ ɖ’v atndd. Ppl r clirli muvd, wɖ sm in ɖ k tōcñ abt ɖer peṛnts’ deʈs or, mor comnli, abt wontñ t b a part v “hisṭri”. Ɖus, mni r nt ɖr t onr ɖ insttyśn v moṇci or a royl indivijl; ẃt z prevḷnt z ɖ xprest nīd t fīl part v smʈñ mor ɖn ɖmslvz.

So hǎ cn deṃcratic poḷtics flfil ɖt fuñśn instd? F w ʈnc abt ǎr cuṛnt p’liticl clas rplesñ moṇci, ɖt z clirli nt ɖ ansr. Hǎ mni prîm̦inistrz in ɖ past 50 yirz wd y k p t pe fînl rspcts t? Probbli nt ɖt mni. Bt ɖr-in lîz a funḍmntl truʈ abt ɖ insttyśn v moṇci – it z a dstrax́n. It z a specṭcl xōltd fr xmpḷfayñ vrćuz ɖt śd b tipicl in public lîf n public bhevyr. Castñ sć bhevyr az xpśnl alǎz ɖ lîcs v Boris Jonsn, Liz Trus n ɖ ic̣nomic ilīts ɖe repriznt t brec n xplôt ɖ rūlz fr ɖer ǒn beṇfit n ɖt v ɖer vri naro clas inṭrest – v ẃć ɖ moṇci z an integṛl part.

Fr haf v Qīn Iliẓbʈ II’z rên, ǎr comn lîf wz dstroid bî ɖ prîṿtîześn v wōtr, eṇji, public transport n caunslhǎzñ, bî ɖ deṣcreśn v ǎr land ʈru fracñ n suij in rivrz, n bî ɖ dspolieśn v ǎr comn wlʈ in ɖ selñ of v ćildṛn’z n eldrli cerhomz t prîṿt-eqti grūps. Ɖs ol tc ples wɖt so mć az a royl mrmr v dis’pruvl.

Yt, at ɖ sem tîm, ɖ royl faṃli manijd t xmt itslf fṛm mor ɖn 160 difṛnt pìsz v lejsleśn fr its ǒn ic̣nomic advantij, sć az ɖ weivñ v ɖ 40% inheritnstax on ɖ crǎn istet’s esṭmetd £15.2bn v royl asets.

So ẃl rpublicnz śd rspct ɖ lanḡj v “dyti” n “sacṛfîs” moṇcists hv so forsḟli clemd ɖt ɖ royl faṃli mcs on ǎr bhaf, w śd nt pritnd ɖt ɖ riaḷti z enʈñ uɖr ɖn a lai. Ɖt z nt ẃt moṇci z. It me pṛvîd a simbolic we fr s t rec̣gnîz uɖr ppl’z sacṛfîs n cmitmnt t ssayti – bt ɖ moṇci itslf riscs nʈñ n dz nt sufr, sev fr hvñ ɖ lîvz v ɖ royl faṃli bcm ɖ stuf v s’lebṛtigosip. Ʈru it ol, it rmenz ɖ bacbon v a pǎrstrucćr ɖt tresz its rūts bac t fyḍlizm.

Ɖ îdīa v dvîn n indiviẓbl sovṛnti imbodid in ɖ moṇc hz bn pást on t parḷmnt. Ɖr it cntinyz t l’jitmîz ɖ pǎr v a clos-nit ilīt cḿṇti rzistnt t ɖ fact ɖt in a complex modn ssayti ol v s hv a stec, n ol śd hv a vôs.

F y dǎt ɖs culćṛl tricl-dǎn n its repḷceśn in ɖ fabric v ǎr sośl, p’liticl n ic̣nomic lîf ɖen simpli lc at ɖ scūlz ǎr Cñ, hiz sunz n ɖ līdrz v inḍstri n fînans atndd. Ītn, Haro, Wsminstr – ɖ trenñcamps fr ɖ nxt jeṇreśn v jenṛlz, captinz v inḍstri n prîm̦inistrz. Phps in a jenyin dmocṛsi, ǎr lejsḷćr cd ofr riyl ćecs n baḷnsz agnst sć hreditri pǎr. Yt mor ɖn haf ǎr lejsḷćr rmenz nt jst unilectd, bt incrisñli dstnḡśt onli bî hvñ hlpt t fund ɖ parti v hreditri priṿlij – ɖ Cnsrṿtiv parti. Anɖr 92 d’recli inheṛtd ɖer xōltd pziśnz.

F w az a cuntri r t muv awe fṛm ɖ constnt deṃcratic gaslîtñ v ɖs p’liticl clas, w mst mc consttyśnl, deṃcratic rform a p’liticl prîoṛti. It z’nt a sîdśo t b reḷgetd bhnd ɖ NHS, ɖ eṇjicrîsis or clîṃt iśuz. Dscuśn v ɖ moṇci, ǎr poḷtics, ǎr consttyśn, z smʈñ t b vigṛsli erd, nt śut dǎn or īvn tmprṛli s’prest.

In a YC ɖt nīdz sć dliḅreśn, mî ǒn parti wd b wîz t gv xpreśn t sć deṃcratic sntimnt.

Bt az w’v sìn ɖs wīc, rpublicnz mst olso ofr smʈñ ɖt gz bynd ɖ mtirịl tecṇcaḷtiz v poḷtics n guvnns. Sacṛfîs, tîmlisnis n ritẏl nīd nt b bǎnd p in ŕmin n gold. W glimst ɖt most rīsntli jrñ ɖ pandemic. Ɖ sns v b’loññ, v smʈñ śerd, ɖ clapñ fr ɖoz hu risct ɖer livz – hu sacṛfîst fr ol v s. Ɖs z gd poḷtics; poḷtics ɖt dmandz v ppl ɖt ɖe smtmz act n fīl in a we ɖt gz bynd ɖmslvz n ẃć z cnctd wɖ ɖ past n fyćr v ǎr ssayti n cḿṇti.

Phps a rpublicn hed v stet cd b reğlrli ćozn fṛm ɖoz hu dsple sć qoḷtiz. Ppl hu pt ɖer livz on ɖ lîn sć az ɖ militri n fîrfîtrz, bt olso ppl hu cmit in uɖr wez lîc nrsz n tīćrz, hu gv p ɖer tîm t cidz huz s’xesz ɖe me nvr liv t si.

Ɖ Britiś ppl hv nvr, ʈru deṃcratic mīnz, bn gvn ɖ ćans t trî smʈñ difṛnt n apruv or rjct consttyśnl moṇci. Instd, ɖoz hu hv x’sîzd ɖer so-cōld deṃcratic rîts hv bn śut dǎn, intiṃdetd or arestd.

Obzrvñ ɖs I wz rmîndd v a Ćînīz mīdịstydnt hu śadoud m ẃl I wz a BBC rportr. Jrñ wn convseśn, I mnśnd ɖ maṣcr v Tiananmen Sqer. Ś hd’nt hŕd v it, so I śoud hr Jon Simsn’z nǎ feṃs rport on ɖ traɉdi. Ś woćt it. Ɖen ś sd: “Yes, ɖs z probbli tru. Bt ɖen I’m fŭli awer v ɖ nećr v ɖ reźīm I liv undr. Bt y? Y dlud yrslf y liv in a dmocṛsi. So hu’z ɖ bigr fūl?” Ś wz rît. It riyli z tîm fr s t wec p n unḍstand ɖ flwd riaḷti v ɖ vri liṃtd dmocṛsi w inhabit.

• • •

Clîv Luis z ɖ Lebr MP fr Norij Sǎʈ

Instroduction to Ñspel